In 2026, vendors are adopting hybrid mesh network security architectures that unify firewalls, SASE, and cloud security under a single policy framework to address the growing complexity of securing distributed enterprise networks.
While this architectural shift promises simplified management and consistent protection across environments, it also raises the bar for security effectiveness. To independently validate how leading vendors perform in this new model, Check Point engaged Miercom to evaluate hybrid mesh network security solutions in a controlled, comparative test.
Miercom conducted competitive security effectiveness testing of Check Point’s Hybrid Mesh Network Security against products from Cisco, Fortinet, Palo Alto Networks and Zscaler. Comprehensive testing was conducted with all vendors’ security services enabled, challenging each solution’s ability to detect and block the latest malware. Modern threats like web-based malware attacks, targeted phishing attacks, application-layer attacks increase the threat level against organizations globally. The majority of new malware and intrusion attempts exploit weaknesses in applications, as opposed to networking components and services.
In this report, Zero+1 Day Malware (up to 24 hours past Zero-Day discovery) refers to newly discovered malware on the first day after discovery. These malware samples are less likely to be known by any vendor’s signature detection mechanisms in the first 24 hours.
Key Findings
Critical Prevention Rate in the first 24 hours: Check Point led the group in immediate prevention of total malware samples. The first 24 hours of a malware campaign are the most dangerous, and this is the critical time to stop an attack before it quickly spreads and creates widespread damage. A security system with a higher block rate in the first 24 hours means an enterprise will be able to stop threats in real-time, minimizing the risk of data breaches, downtime, and damage from advanced persistent threats (APTs). This proactive capability enhances organizational resilience, and ensures future-proof security in an ever-evolving threat landscape.
Malware Prevention vs. Detection: Check Point prevented 99.9% of new malware from a comprehensive set of file types including DOCX, XLSX, PDFs, EXEs, APKs, DLLs and archived files that were no more than 24 hours
- Check Point led with the highest score preventing 99.9% of malware downloads.
- Palo Alto Networks had 66.1% prevention and 12.1% detect-only.
- Fortinet had 69.9% prevention.
- Cisco had 68.4% prevention and 10.4% detect-only.
- Zscaler had 64% prevention.
Remote User Malware Prevention (SSE):
- Check Point led with a 99.8% total block rate.
- Cisco had a 97% total block rate.
- Fortinet had a 66.8% total block rate.
- Palo Alto Networks had a 65.4% total block rate.
- Zscaler had a 64% total block rate.
Phishing Prevention: Recent phishing URLs confirmed active were used to evaluate detection performance across multiple vendors’ security solutions. Because phishing campaigns are short-lived and URLs often go online and offline quickly, the results highlight the limitations of static URL filtering databases and the advantage of AI systems capable of analyzing page behavior and content in real time.
Check Point proved to have the best overall prevention against phishing URLs, making use of (R82) advanced AI deep learning capabilities.
- Check Point led with a 100% prevention rate with no missed URLs.
- Palo Alto Networks had a 98.48% prevention rate with five missed URLs.
- Zscaler had a 94.5% prevention rate with 19 missed URLs.
- Fortinet had an 87.8% prevention rate with 41 missed URLs.
- Cisco had a 16% prevention rate with 279 missed URLs.
Remote User Phishing Prevention (SSE):
- Check Point led with a 99.7% prevention rate with one missed URL.
- Zscaler had a 94.5% prevention rate with 18 missed URLs.
- Palo Alto Networks had a 92.8% prevention rate with 22 missed URLs.
- Fortinet had an 86.6% prevention rate with 41 missed URLs.
- Cisco had a 25.8% prevention rate with 227 missed URLs.
Intrusion Prevention System: BreakingPoint IPS is a network security testing tool designed to simulate real-world traffic, including cyberattacks, to evaluate and optimize performance of IPS.
- Check Point led with a 99.49% block rate.
- Fortinet had a 94.18% block rate.
- Palo Alto Networks had an 92.56% block rate.
- Cisco had an 87% block rate.
Intrusion Prevention System: (CISA KEV)
- Check Point led with a 99.87% block rate.
- Fortinet had a 97.5% block rate.
- Palo Alto Networks had an 89.36% block rate.
- Cisco had an 86.73% block rate.
Weighted Secure Browsing Speed:
Speed Test:
- Check Point led with an average of 1.12 Gbps.
- Palo Alto Networks had an average of 491 Mbps.
- Fortinet had an average of 72 Mbps.
- Cisco had an average of 503 Mbps.
- Zscaler had an average of 559 Mbps.
File Download Test:
- Check Point led with an average of 74.9 ms for 10MB file / 7.07 ms for 1MB file.
- Fortinet had an average of 511 ms for 10MB file / 18.7 ms for 1MB file.
- Cisco had an average of 377.2 ms for 10MB file / 3.1 ms for 1MB file.
- Palo Alto Networks had an average of 283 ms for 10MB file / 20 ms for 1MB file.
- Zscaler had an average of 132.7 ms for 10MB file / 20.6 ms for 1MB file.
Cybersecurity and Infrastructure (CISA) Known Exploited Vulnerabilities (KEV): CISA maintains the KEV Catalog, an authoritative repository of vulnerabilities that have been exploited in real-world cyberattacks. These figures reflect the number of known exploited vulnerabilities associated with each product as documented in the CISA KEV Catalog.
- Check Point ranked the best with only 1 KEV.
- Palo Alto Networks has 13 KEVs.
- Fortinet has 24 KEVs.
- Cisco has 30 KEVs.
As a SASE vendor, Zscaler’s score is not applicable since the solution is fully managed by the vendor, eliminating the need to report KEVs.
Read more about how Check Point earned the Miercom Certified Secure award and review the testing results featured in Hybrid Mesh Network Security Miercom Competitive Assessment 2026 study.